Skip to Content

York Peppermint Brownies, Remixed

York Peppermint Brownies!!!

York Peppermint Brownies

This recipe has gotten more views than any recipe I have ever posted since I’ve been writing this blog… ever. The problem is that it was one of the very FIRST recipes I ever posted, so the photos were GARBAGE. Not that I’m any kind of professional food photographer now or anything… ummmm no. Most of what I’ve picked up in the photo department has been from the Tasty Food Photography e-book written by Lindsay from A Pinch of Yum. Teaching is SO her calling.

Anyway, besides the photos looking like I set a toddler loose with a cheap camera phone, I’ve had several comments and even more emails asking for photos of the finished product as well as a little help.

homemade brownie batter

So I’ma try to help a little bit.

Several readers have contacted me about the peppermint patties rising up and making an ugly (but delicious) mess out of these brownies. I made a few batches and couldn’t figure out the problem… until I bumped the temperature up a little bit. 350 instead of 325 made a few peppermint patties bust through the top of the brownies. All ovens cook differently- mine runs super hot – so if you’ve had problems with a York Peppermint Brownie mess, check your oven temp.

baked homemade brownies

I’ve had a few inquiries about the brand of peppermint patty– I always use York, but I don’t think it matters. I’ve had a a couple of readers use After Eights with total success. And here’s the great thing about brownies: you can pretty much put whatever you want in them.

Reese’s cups? Yes. Pretzels? Definitely. Thin mint Girl Scout Cookies? Ohhhh my gosh yes. Also if someone can procure some Thin Mints, Samoas, and Tagalongs for me I will… I don’t really know yet, but I’ll do something super thankful and great.

we ate the whole pan of brownies

If you want the exact specifics of the brownies shown in these photos, here it is: I used a 9 X 9 pan (my original recipe calls for an 8 X 8, but I exploded mine in the oven one day… now 9 X 9 works just fine for me.) and THIS brownie recipe. It’s my favorite basic brownie recipe using chocolate chips instead of cocoa powder. The results are dense and fudgey with that thin crinkly wisp of chocolate that bakes up across the top. I love them. I spread half the brownie batter across the bottom of the pan and then evenly spaced 16 snack size York Peppermint Patties over the batter. Then I spread the other half over the top of the peppermint patties.

In a 9 X 9 pan I had to streeeeetch it, but it worked. I baked ’em for 30 minutes at 325.

And I let them cool completely before cutting (if you are not concerned with appearances please feel free to eat them warm from the pan with a fork… I might or might not be guilty of this).

York Peppermint Brownies

I hope this helps!! Thanks for all the comments, emails, and feedback- I was really glad to have an excuse to make 3 batches of these again. Tasty research and all that.

For the original York Peppermint Brownie post click HERE.

peppermint brownie recipe

Pinterest Success: Peppermint Patty Brownies! - Sunshine Whispers

Wednesday 30th of July 2014

[…] How would you like the secret to one of the easiest, most crowd-pleasing recipes I have discovered in quite a long time? Ladies, may I introduce you to the Peppermint Patty Brownies! I first discovered this recipe on Pinterest via the fantastic foodie blog, Sugar Dish Me. You can find the original recipe here: […]

Hayley @ The Domestic Rebel

Thursday 31st of January 2013

You had me at "crinkly wisp." LOVEEEE. So liiiike, I am still totally obsessed with aforementioned brownie wisp (btw, 'wisp' is much a cuter word than 'skin' which is what I was previously using and made me sound like a brownie cannibal) and I had no idea that using chocolate chips vs cocoa powder would give me more of that tasty, luscious skin--er, wisp. IN LOVE.

PS, I swear I'm not a cannibal.


Thursday 31st of January 2013

Your comments are cracking me up right now. I'm not sure if it's the chocolate chips that produce that result? It might be though because my Starbucks double fudge brownie recipe uses melted chocolate AND cocoa and it is wisp-less. So any way... IF you were to be a cannibal of some kind, brownie cannibal would be the best I think. Wispy skin = Amazing brownie. I think that was an SAT analogy.

York Peppermint Brownies… Oh Yes. « Sugar Dish Me

Thursday 31st of January 2013

[...] **********UPDATE 1/30/2013: First I’d like to say a great big huge THANK YOU for reading Sugar Dish Me; the response on this post has been great!! Second… many of you have left comments and sent emails with questions about this recipe, and while I have addressed those issues specifically to each individual, I wrote an updated post (with better photos, including the finished product!!) to help. Several readers have had trouble with the peppermint patties busting through the top of the brownies while baking- advice on that is included. You can find the updated post HERE. [...]

Allison@Main St. Cuisine

Wednesday 30th of January 2013

Now I know exactly what to do with one of the many boxes of thin mints we ordered from multiple Girl Scouts this year. These look amazing, Heather! I can see why so many readers would love these!


Wednesday 30th of January 2013

Ummm.. I am so jealous of your Thin Mints. I can't get a Girl Scout cookie to save my life!! I need a stack of Thin Mints and an armload of Samoas. Forget the brownies!!!


Wednesday 30th of January 2013

WHY DO YOU DO THIS TO ME?! Hahahaha!! god, these look good! I could definitely scarf down a pan full with fork or without right now! Plus, I leanred something new - I learned the phrase "peppermint patty" which to begin with ahd me entirely confused, until I realised it was an After Eight!


Wednesday 30th of January 2013

The girl that emailed me and made them with the After Eights lived in Spain! Hahaha. It's good that these brownies are gone right now because in my current state today I would SO eat the whole pan with a fork. And chase it with Boozey Hot Chocolate.