Skip to Content

Tried and Tested Reader Favorite Recipes

Tried and Tested Reader Favorite Recipes, for when you don’t wanna guess to know if it’s all gonna work out. You just know. 

The Best Tried and Tested Recipes on Sugar Dish Me

Year after year I turn out new recipes here that I have tested over and over in my own kitchen, and served up to my own family, and so far no one hates me for giving them the same From Scratch Stew Beef 3 times in a week. But there are always a few favorites – things that you all – My Readers! The Bread and Butter of this blog – really take and run with. 

These are YOUR favorites. The recipes you have tried and tested in your own home kitchens, offered up feedback on, shared tips on how to make ahead or freeze, and have given all the love.

I thought they should all live in one place, so that if you came here because you found one, you might also want to try some others! 

There’s something for everyone here. A little sweet, a little savory, some breakfast (my fave), and the BEST biscuits on earth. Not even joking. 

If you have other favorites I’d love to hear about them! Also tagging me on Instagram with your successes is a little bit my favorite. 

Tried and Tested Reader Favorite Recipes

Readers find this site in all sorts of ways, but there are a few posts that are favorites no matter the season, or how many years have passed since that recipe was made. So I wanted to put ALL the Tried and Tested Reader Favorite Recipes from Sugar Dish Me in one place, and give you a good resource to see what other readers are making.

10 Minute Pizza Dough

Yup. 10 minutes! This 10 Minute Pizza Dough Recipe has hundreds of reader reviews and success stories. Skip the delivery. Your pizza at home is way better.

Get the Recipe

Buffalo Chicken Lettuce Wraps

Can you go wrong with buffalo anything? My answer is NO. Buffalo Chicken Lettuce Wraps

Get the Recipe

Kick Ass Chicken Lasagna

Kick Ass Chicken Lasagna kicks all the ass (duh). Cheese and chicken, and is actually my very favorite comfort food.

Continue Reading

The Best Meatloaf Sandwich I've Ever Had

The Best Meatloaf Sandwich is  equal parts hearty and handheld. It's saucy, there's cheese, and it really is the best. I promise. 

Continue Reading

Chicken Philly Sandwiches

This Chicken Philly Sandwich Recipe has been getting rave reviews for years! Don't come out here talking about Cheez Whiz. These have chopped, seasoned chicken, onions, peppers, mushrooms, and my favorite cheese sauce ever.

Get the Recipe

Low and Slow Mustard Glazed Blade Pork Roast

Mustard Glazed Blade Pork Roast (also known as a Boston Butt Roast) is cooked in the oven low and slow. You don’t need a fancy smoker to enjoy a good plate of barbecue.

Get the Recipe

Apple Cinnamon Stovetop Oatmeal

If you love apple pie or apple crumble, you’ll LOVE this Apple Cinnamon Stovetop Oatmeal! Warm, cozy, and loaded with cooked apples plus all the delicious spices.

Get the Recipe

The Biggest, Fattest, Fluffiest All Butter Biscuits

The Biggest fattest Fluffiest All Butter Biscuits are everything you ever wanted in a homemade biscuit recipe. Flaky tender layers, butter, and perfectly browned tops. The height on these babies is ridiculous.

Get the Recipe

Homemade Fluffy Pancake Mix

This easy homemade mix turns out THE BEST, fluffiest pancakes! Homemade Fluffy Pancake Mix makes breakfast simple - just add an egg and milk.

Get the Recipe

Giant Cinnamon Rolls

It doesn’t get much more indulgent than Giant Cinnamon Rolls the size of your hand! You can make this coffee house favorite right at home! Let’s learn how.

Continue Reading

The Easiest Blackberry Cobbler

My favorite summer cobbler recipe! Fresh blackberries are piled right on top of an easy batter that will rise up right over them as it bakes. A classic recipe to keep on hand!

Get the Recipe

Pinot Noir Brownies

Pinot Noir Brownies are the richest, fudgiest brownies I have EVER made. They are dense, loaded with dark chocolate, and have WINE in them!

Continue Reading
13 Lemon Recipes to Brighten Your Day - cake with text
Lemon Recipes to Brighten Up Your Day
Twice Baked Breakfast Potatoes topped with bacon and parsley
Twice Baked Breakfast Potatoes